Artificial Intelligence (AI) is poised to revolutionize the workplace by automating tasks, improving efficiency, and boosting productivity. But there’s a darker side to this rosy picture that businesses are struggling with. These technologies, though revolutionary, have also been a source of frustration for some.
Drowning in AI-Generated Submissions
Neil Clarke, an editor and publisher, recently experienced an onslaught of AI-generated submissions for his magazine, Clarkesworld. Describing the influx of content as “consistently bad,” Clarke explains that the problem isn’t necessarily the quality, but the sheer volume of submissions that’s overwhelming his team.
“The quantity is burying us,” he lamented, noting that the issue has nearly doubled their workload and has forced them to close submissions more than once.
AI: A Boost to Productivity or A Thorn in The Side?
Prominent figures in the tech world, including Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates, have touted the potential of AI to streamline work, generate jobs, and improve efficiency. However, the reality can be more complicated, with unforeseen consequences and uneven impacts across different sectors.
AI-powered tools, which are being rapidly developed by big tech companies, can draft emails, create presentations, and summarize large volumes of data. But there are also instances where they have caused issues, such as generating fake court citations or bombarding small publications with computer-generated content.
The Real Impact of AI on Work
In a study conducted by MIT, researchers found that using ChatGPT increased productivity for tasks such as writing cover letters and conducting cost-benefit analyses. Yet, they also acknowledged that the implications of AI in the workplace are still largely uncertain.
The Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) has found that while AI can enhance certain job aspects, it also intensifies work and has a minimal impact on wages for non-specialists. This suggests that workers are handling more responsibility without seeing a commensurate rise in their pay.
Workers as ‘Guinea Pigs’
Ivana Saula, Research Director for the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, shared that workers often feel like “guinea pigs” during the rushed implementation of AI tools. This has led to an increase in “residual tasks” that humans still need to handle, creating more work pressure.
“It’s never just clean cut, where the machine can entirely replace the human,” Saula said, emphasizing the need for more worker involvement during AI implementation.
AI’s Impact on Media
In the media industry, AI holds the potential to automate copywriting and advertising. However, this has not always been a smooth process. CNET and Gizmodo have experienced challenges and have had to issue corrections on AI-written articles.
To tackle AI-generated submission issues, Neil Clarke has attempted to use AI-powered detectors, but found them unreliable due to high rates of false positives and false negatives.
As AI continues to evolve, it’s clear that achieving a balance between automation and human interaction will be crucial. While AI can indeed deliver significant breakthroughs, its current impact on the workplace indicates a need for careful consideration and implementation.
Related Articles
